Has Ari Aster become the most interesting screenwriter working in Hollywood?

Genre: Political Thriller/Dark Comedy
Premise: When a controversial far-right influencer dies during brain surgery, the neurosurgeon responsible becomes the target of an increasingly violent conspiracy campaign led by the dead man’s brother.
About: Ari Aster follows up his politically charged Eddington with another politically charged screenplay, Scapegoat. Aster, whose previous films include Hereditary, Midsommar, and Beau Is Afraid, has become one of the most unpredictable filmmakers working today. And judging by this latest script, he’s not interested in becoming any more predictable.
Writer: Ari Aster
Details: 133 pages (May 2026 draft)

One of the most common notes I give screenwriters who send me screenplays is that this was a very pleasant screenplay. It was well written. It was effortless to read. It had a clear plot. It had characters trying to do things.

And guess what? That’s the worst kind of script you can write. Something that’s pleasant. Because pleasant is forgettable.

But it’s hard to come up with examples of what a non-pleasant script looks like to help these writers out. Well, I’ve got one here today. It’s called Scapegoat by Ari Aster. This is the OPPOSITE of a pleasant script. Which means it’s the type of script that anybody who reads it will never forget.

I want to say right off the bat that this review has MAJOR SPOILERS. So if you want to experience your Ari Aster movie spoiler-free, STOP READING.

Dr. Susan Meyerstein is performing brain surgery on a young man named Galen Krause when the operation unexpectedly goes wrong and he dies.

Susan is devastated, but things get worse when she discovers that Galen was a hugely influential far-right political personality. His brother Evan becomes convinced that Susan deliberately murdered him and unleashes his millions of followers on her.

As Susan’s personal life starts to fall apart and the threats intensify, Evan begins connecting Galen’s death to Debbie Berger, the widow of another prominent political figure.

And just when we think we’re watching an innocent woman being destroyed by conspiracy theorists, Aster reveals something astonishing: Susan actually DID murder Galen after someone kidnapped her husband and threatened to kill him unless she sabotaged the operation. Ho-lee Shit.

Yesterday, I was at a coffee shop and I met this girl from Canada who revealed to me that she just moved to LA to become a screenwriter, and I said, “Oh, that’s funny, I run a screenwriting website. I’ve read more scripts than you can count.”

She then asked me, “Well, you probably know right away if a script isn’t working.” And I said, “Yep, I most definitely do.” She said, “Well, how do you know?” And I said, “Well, it would take 5 hours to give you all the tells but I’ll give you the most basic one, which is that the writer starts off with a boring scene.”

“You’re sitting there as the reader thinking, you could have started with ANYTHING. This is the ENTRY into your movie. This is the very first thing you’re writing. And you chose to write a boring scene. To set up a character in a boring way, set up a plot point in a boring way. It may be the biggest sin a writer can make.”

Then I went to sit down, opened my laptop, and pulled out today’s script. Lo and behold, it starts out with a RIVETING sequence.

We follow this guy into the hospital, Galen. We don’t know who he is. We just know that he has a tumor in his head, and it’s a relatively small one. As far as brain tumor surgeries go, this is supposed to be a pretty run-of-the-mill operation.

So this doctor comes in, Susan. She seems very confident about the whole thing, and all of it is so detailed and so real. You really feel like you’re in that hospital room, and that you’re Galen. You’re this guy about to get surgery.

And so you’re scared, of course, because you’re like, well, things do go wrong, but she seems extremely confident about this and how it’s all going to be fine. She’s even talking about what you’re going to need to do after the surgery, and it just seems like everything is going to go fine.

And then we get into the surgery room. And we watch the surgery in real time, and it just starts to fall apart. One thing starts to go wrong, then two, then three, and they start to compound. And the next thing you know, Galen dies.

And we’re SHOCKED because we thought that Galen was the main character. But that’s when we realize that actually Susan is the main character.

So we follow Susan as she deals with the disturbing reality of what just happened, and what it feels like to be a doctor who loses someone on the table. We want to know what the heck happens next, because we figure she’s in a lot of trouble with the hospital, and this could affect her job. We think it’s going to be that kind of movie.

But then what we learn is that the guy she lost on the table was this huge online right-wing influencer. And she doesn’t use social media, but her daughter calls her and says, “Listen, people are posting your picture on social media. They’re posting where you live. They’re posting your car, your license plate number.”

And that’s when Susan realizes, and we realize, that she’s in a loooooootttttt of trouble, and that this is a much bigger deal than losing one person during surgery.

And Aster continues to pile on the details. He’s a very detail-oriented writer where he really thinks about who these people are and what’s going on. We see Susan go to her car after work and the first thing she does is take a breathalyzer test to start the car.

So now we’re sitting there thinking, HOLY SHIT, this woman was an alcoholic?? And she’s allowed to operate on people?? She’s allowed to, like, operate on people’s BRAINS??? This is starting to get crazy. And then we learn that her husband is so fed up with her because she’s such an alcoholic that he just ditched her. He said, “I’m out.” He texted her that he needs time away.

So she’s freaking out about her marriage, and she just wants to see her husband again, and now the hospital’s looking into what happened during the operation, and everything online keeps getting worse. People start saying that she’s Jewish, and that she was clearly paid by the Jews to kill Galen. And it really becomes this sort of political commentary on just how out of control the extreme right has become.

And that’s when Ari Aster does something that no other writer would dare do. He says, “Well, what if all those evil people on the far right who came up with this conspiracy theory… WHAT IF THEY WERE RIGHT?”

And so the movie flashes back, and that’s when we learn that two weeks ago Susan got a visit from somebody who said, “Listen, you’re going to be the doctor who does brain surgery on Galen in two weeks. We have your husband. If Galen doesn’t die during that operation, your husband dies.”

And so we learn that she DID kill him. She DID murder Galen. And it’s just this crazy creative choice that makes us reevaluate everything we saw. Now we’re sitting there going, HOLY SHIT, well, where is this gonna go?

And being Ari Aster, he makes sure that it goes to the craziest of places. Because even though Susan did what she was supposed to do, the bad guys haven’t delivered her husband back. So she goes looking for him. But then Galen’s brother comes to her and says, “You need to kill Debbie (Galen’s nemesis) or we’re going to kill your daughter.” And meanwhile detectives pay Susan a visit and start asking more questions about that surgery. Oh, and there’s also a nuclear threat going on in Illinois that’s escalating by the hour.

Aster is taking a HUGE RISK here. And he’s pretty freaking brave for it. Cause just like Eddington, he’s not towing the Hollywood political line about who needs to be scolded and who needs to be celebrated. We thought we were all in on an “alt right is bad” moral tale. But when the alt right is right, then where does the moral needle land? I personally think he’s crazy for doing this, since this is probably the same reason Hollywood didn’t get behind Eddington. But, hey, this is what makes Aster Aster.

In the end, I thought the script was good. The third act is nuts, just like Eddington. Actually, just like all his movies. But dude, Ari, do you really want to keep playing this game of making movies about politics? There’s so much hate in the world and you’re asking audiences to put that hate down for two hours so they can… go watch some more hate. I don’t think that’s what movies are for.

I get what he’s doing. He wants to make horror movies where the horror is real life. But it’s hard to market these things. It’s hard to get people to see them. I think Ari’s biggest blind spot is marketing. He needs to learn how to write movies that people actually want to see.

What about you guys? What did you think of the script?

[ ] What the hell did I just read?
[ ] wasn’t for me
[x] worth the read
[ ] impressive
[ ] genius

What I Learned: Detail. The more detail you add to a scene, the more believable it is. A big reason why that opening surgery scene is so captivating is how much detail is included about the surgery itself, the instruments being used, the medicine being used, the interaction between surgeon and assistants. It’s a riveting scene. A disturbing one. But riveting. Because of the attention to detail.

So I finally saw this movie Hope over the weekend. It’s a Korean monster movie where something terrifying invades a large town, and that’s all I knew about it. But I was curious because it initially got a lot of attention when it premiered at the Cannes Film Festival earlier this year.

If you haven’t heard of the movie, Hope is the name of the large harbor town where the story takes place. It starts off with this police chief looking into the strange, violent death of a cow. He’s quickly pulled to another spot outside of town where another cow has been brutally killed.

Then some locals find a human arm hanging from a tree, and now they know that they’re dealing with something much more serious than a random animal attack. The police chief heads back into town, where he discovers that a lot of local stores have been destroyed, and lots of people slaughtered.

From there, it turns into this relentless pursuit of whatever’s responsible for this carnage, which eventually turns out to be a monster. And our police chief and deputy do everything in their power to stop it. And that’s the movie. It’s very straightforward.

I’m going to go on the record and say that this movie gets messy. But it’s about as beautiful as messy gets. So, there’s still a lot to learn. Starting with how it deals with suspense, something that has become a lost art in Hollywood.

Hollywood these days seems to have totally forgotten how to use this storytelling tool, particularly in relation to monster reveals. Because if you go back to the greatest monster-reveal behind-the-scenes story ever, Jaws, that story became huge specifically because Spielberg had originally planned to show a lot more of the shark throughout the movie.

But the shark had all these mechanical issues that have been well documented. So they couldn’t show it nearly as much as they wanted to. They had to rely on things like the fin, the barrels, and underwater point-of-view shots, and wait until roughly 80 minutes into the movie to give us our first full look at the shark.

Ironically, that became one of the most celebrated things about the movie. How long Spielberg made us wait to see the monster. And so that became this sort of calling card in Hollywood for a while. You had to wait to reveal the monster. You had to wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, because Jaws did it.

And the irony was that Spielberg hadn’t originally planned to withhold the shark that long. He was forced to because the thing didn’t work. And this raises a fascinating question about being an artist and the choices we make. Because we’re constantly asking ourselves, are we making the right choice? Is this the best possible way to tell this story?

And here’s one of the greatest filmmakers of all time, making one of the greatest movies of all time, and one of the defining creative decisions came about because he couldn’t execute his original vision. Think about that. It can fuck with your head, no doubt.

But the glazing of revealing the monster later dimmed over time as audiences and studios became less and less patient. We started revealing the monster earlier and earlier. It got so bad that we actually started revealing it BEFORE the movie started, in the trailer!

But then Hope comes along and reminds you of the power of waiting to reveal the monster, which is that it creates this incredible, sustained line of suspense. The monster in Hope isn’t revealed until minute 45. And because we’re so conditioned to meeting these monsters early, sometimes in the very first scene, it feels like hours have passed. It’s a reminder of just how powerful suspense is.

Because we’re so curious what this thing is, because we’re so determined to find out what has wreaked all this havoc, there’s no way you can watch this movie and turn it off before minute 45. There’s just no way. And that’s how you know you’re doing suspense right. The viewer is incapable of turning off your movie because you’ve pulled that line of suspense so taut that they HAVE to keep watching.

And the trick to stretching suspense that long is to give the viewer tastes. You want them to hear the danger. You want them to see objects thrown by this thing. You want them to see movement through windows. But you don’t want them to actually see the danger itself.

Hope does all of that, and it does it so effectively, that by minute 45, we’re DYING to see this thing. And then we finally see it, and it’s like, wow.

But that wasn’t the only great thing about this movie. I think one of the problems with suspense, and specifically suspense involving a monster reveal, is that movies always need an engine underneath them. They need something that’s driving our interest in what’s going on.

And suspense is one of the greatest ways to achieve that. So Hope achieves that for the first 45 minutes.

But what happens when you reveal the monster? What happens when the suspense is over? What do you do then?

That’s where a lot of writers fall apart. And I think where Hope elevates instead of falls is that this monster is unlike any monster we’ve ever seen before.

Let me take a quick detour and point out that familiarity can be useful in storytelling. If you write a movie about zombies, for example, there’s an advantage to having those established rules. Because we already understand how zombies work, and that allows the writer to play with those rules, reinvent them, expand them.

So I’m not saying you should always create an original monster. But this movie shows you what happens when you give us something we’ve never seen before. Because this monster doesn’t make sense.

It’s got long hair, yet it’s covered with lesions. It’s gigantic. It’s extremely muscular. And it’s insanely fast. We don’t know what we’re looking at.

And so that creates A SECOND ENGINE moving forward from the first one, which is that now we have to figure out what the hell this thing is. I’ve never seen anything like this before. Now I want to know what we’re dealing with. Where did it come from? Why is it here? What does it want?

So once again, I’m pulled in, and I need to keep watching. I need to keep turning the pages. That brings me to the monster itself. This is one of the best monsters I’ve seen in movies in a long time. And I’m going to tell you why.

It’s because I find that most writers put muzzles on their monsters. They realize that if they make their monsters too powerful, they’ll kill the protagonist right away and the movie will be over.

So they put muzzles on them. Or they give their heroes plot armor. The monster backs away at just the moment it’s about to kill someone for some unknown reason. Or a military helicopter shows up at the exact moment the monster’s about to kill our protagonist and shoots the monster back.

And the problem with this is that once you do it a few times in your script, we know the protagonists are fine. We know they’re never really going to be in trouble. And the harm that does to your screenplay is immeasurable.

Because in a script where there’s a monster and the reader feels safe, you’ve already failed. I just read a consultation script this week where this was my main note. Your monsters are not scary. I do not fear them. They are not enough of a danger to our protagonist.

If you want to know how to create a monster that is truly terrifying, just throw in Terminator 2. Throw in Terminator 2 and watch the T-1000.

Watch how relentless that thing is. Watch how it will stop at nothing to destroy our protagonist. There is no convenient plot armor. There’s just a Terminator desperately trying, doing everything in its power, to hold this thing back.

But other than that, the thing is insanely terrifying and unstoppable. And that’s what you want your villain or your monster to feel like. You want it to feel unstoppable.

Hope’s monster reminded me of the T-1000, and it’s the first time in a long time that I’ve encountered an antagonist, villain, or monster that reminded me of that level of intensity. There’s this terrifying scene early on where our police chief sprints onto a street, and this thing is chasing him, and it comes sliding around the corner and starts chasing him at this absolutely terrifying speed.

And I remember feeling so much fear in that moment for our protagonist. So please stop putting muzzles on your monsters, guys. This movie shows you the advantage of taking the muzzle off.

Unfortunately, structurally, Hope is kind of a mess. After we attempt to figure out what this thing is (they dissect it), a group of secondary protagonists stumble upon a crashed ship in the forest. And that’s when we realize there are more of these monsters. So don’t get comfortable yet. But it does introduce a new line of suspense (where are the other monsters if not in their ship) that revs things up again.

The problem is that Hope repeats itself a lot. We’ve already seen creatures try to kill our characters. And these new ones aren’t that different from the old one. Too much repetition can kill a script and whoever wrote this didn’t realize that a 160 minute movie is way too long. This is why one of the first things you learn in screenwriting is to GET RID OF THE FAT. Which, in this case, means get rid of the repetition.

Had the writers and filmmakers sat down and had a genuine discussion about this, getting rid of 45 pages (which would’ve taken the movie down to 1 hour and 55 minutes) we’d be talking about an all time classic. Movies with visually aggressive storylines should never be long.

In spite of this, the movie is still a treat because of everything I mentioned above, as well as, it just FEELS different. The point of view here, no doubt inspired by the region the movie was born out of, gives it a flavor none of us has tasted before. And it tasted good!

Screenplays due this coming Thursday! Contest is FREE!

For years, aspiring writers have complained that the Black List scripts aren’t even that good. That they only get featured because the writers have agents. If you had an agent sending out your script, it would eclipse all these garbage Black List titles.

Well, NOW’S YOUR CHANCE TO PROVE IT. One week from today, on Friday, November 20th, we’re going to have our first ever Better Than the Black List Showdown!

The Black List will be released on the second weekend in December and, when it does, I will review the winning Black List script and, the next day, the winning Amateur Showdown script.

Guys, there’s a lot on the line here. I want to embarrass Franklin Leonard. I want to show what one weekend here on Scriptshadow is capable of. So, if you have a screenplay, you better submit it moth#$%&@er. We gotta take this list DOWN.

I need your…

1) Title
2) Genre
3) Logline
4) Why You Think it Deserves A Shot (Optional)
5) A PDF of your screenplay
6) AI Generated Poster (Optional)

Send all entries to: CARSONREEVES3@GMAIL.COM
Subject Line: “Better”

DEADLINE: Thursday, November 19th, 8pm Pacific Time

I don’t have a ton of time so I’m writing this post off the cuff. Buyer beware. When I heard that James Gunn was gone just four years into his regime at DC, I was a little shocked. I mean, I knew with the barely acceptable box office of Clayface that something was coming. I’m not sure I knew they were going to completely destroy DC.

If you’re looking for a breakdown of how badly things went, Variety has an article on the implosion. But what interests me isn’t so much the business side of this disaster. It’s the writing side.

Because the more I look at what Gunn was trying to do, the more I realize that a lot of his instincts were good. So how did it all go wrong? More importantly, what can screenwriters learn from it?

Let’s start with something that made me laugh. After making Superman, Gunn said it was the greatest filmmaking experience of his life. And my immediate reaction was, “Well of course it was! For the first time in your career, you were making a movie with no oversight. You were the boss! I’d be pretty happy with that kind of freedom myself.”

After Gunn got fired, he immediately went to his favorite place, Twitter, to chat with the people. He talked about how much he hated the administrative side of running DC Studios. The meetings. The endless responsibilities that came with overseeing a studio.

Does that sound familiar?

It should. Because I would argue that WE’RE ALL JAMES GUNN.

Every aspiring screenwriter who works a job they don’t particularly love so they can pay the bills is dealing with this problem. You want to write. You want to create. You want to spend your day coming up with amazing characters and unforgettable scenes. But you can’t. Because you’ve got a job. And that job doesn’t give a shit about your dreams.

That job wants you there at 9 a.m. It wants you to answer emails. It wants you to deal with annoying customers and impossible deadlines and that coworker who somehow turned a five-minute minor issue into a three-hour meeting.

By the time you’re finished? You’re exhausted. Your brain is fried. The last thing you want to do is write. And this is where James Gunn gets a lot of credit.

THE MAN WRITES.

He wrote Superman. He wrote Man of Tomorrow. He’s probably rewriting all these other DC movies and shows. He recently wrote another secret project.

That’s the mentality you need. Because it’s easy to convince yourself that your circumstances are difficult. That nobody understands how draining your job is. That if you could just get six months off, you could finally write that screenplay. But the truth is, there’s never going to be a perfect time.

You’re always going to have responsibilities. You’re always going to have something competing for your attention. And if you’re waiting for the day when writing becomes convenient, you’ll be waiting for the rest of your life.

It reminds me of that one aspiring writer from the early days of Scriptshadow who some of you may remember. He sent me a screenplay and explained he’d written the entire thing on his phone. Every day, during his commute to work, he’d pull out his phone and write. I remember making fun of that script because, well, it definitely READ like it had been written on a phone.

But looking back, I realize I was focused on the wrong thing. The screenplay wasn’t bad because he’d written it on his phone. It was bad because he was a beginner screenwriter.

From a purely hustling standpoint, the fact that he wrote a screenplay on the way to work every day was fucking inspiring. I remember that he had a family and, technically, no time to write during the day. SO HE MADE TIME.

I read a similar story about a book editor, Gail Honeyman, who not-so-secretly wanted to be an author. But her day job of editing made it difficult. So she freaking got up 2 hours earlier every morning, at 5am, and wrote then. SHE MADE TIME. And she ended up writing a really great book called Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine.

These people get things done. And that’s the exact mentality you need. If you’ve got 30 minutes, write for 30 minutes. If you’ve got an hour, write for an hour. If you’ve got an electric car, set it to automatic drive on your commute and write then. Okay, maybe don’t do that. I don’t want to be sued if you plow into a Yum Yum donut shop. Unless it’s a really good scene. Then it may be worth it.

And that’s the big lesson I take away from James Gunn’s DC experience. No matter how busy you are, no matter how demanding your job is, no matter how mentally exhausted you feel, you have to figure out a way to write.

Now let’s talk about the actual DC movies, because one of the biggest criticisms of Gunn’s approach was that he kept focusing on characters who weren’t popular. Supergirl. Clayface. Green Lantern.

Meanwhile, the biggest character in the entire DC universe was sitting right there. Danuhnuhnuh Danuhnuhnuh BAAAATMAAAAAN!

And somehow, Gunn never got to use him. Somehow, Matt Reeves, who takes longer to make a movie than some ice ages, had veto power over Gunn, the head of the company, for using Robert Pattinson. And we’re not ever sure that Gunn liked Pattinson. As I’m writing this I’m realizing there’s a very good possibility that Gunn was fired because of Batman. Because if he got to make a Batman film, for sure he has a shot at a billion dollar gross. And if he has a billion dollar DC superhero movie on his resume, they ain’t firing him this week.

Despite that, I still get why Gunn was choosing the characters he chose. Supergirl was about a deeply troubled woman dealing with grief, trauma, and addiction. If we’re all being honest with ourselves, that’s a pretty interesting starting point for a superhero movie.

Then you have Clayface. A body-horror movie about a man whose identity is literally falling apart. That’s a potentially incredible vehicle for exploring identity, self-worth, and what happens when someone loses the thing that defines them.

Then there’s Lanterns. Gunn wanted to explore what happens when a superhero gets older. What happens when the excitement wears off? When a guy who’s spent his life being celebrated starts coasting on that reputation? Put that character alongside a younger, more idealistic Green Lantern, and suddenly you’ve got a slick sounding buddy-cop show.

Again, that’s a legitimate dramatic premise.

So why didn’t any of these ideas work? Well, because screenwriting is a very, very, very, VERY tricky thing. You see, a screenplay is, and will always be, a living breathing organism.

When you sit down to write one of these slippery suckers, you have an idea of what movie you’re going to write. You know the tone. You know the characters. You know what the story is supposed to be about. Then you start writing and somewhere along the way, the screenplay starts talking back to you.

It says, “You know that movie you wanted to write? Well, I actually think it’d be more interesting if we went in THIS direction.” And you think, “Huh. That’s actually a pretty good idea.” So you follow it. And since your plot starts changing, your characters have to change. Which means their arcs have to change. Which means the theme has to change.

Before you know it, you’re writing a different movie from the one you originally conceived. This happens ALL THE TIME in writing. And here’s the problem. Sometimes the new movie is better. But sometimes it’s not. Sometimes you’ve followed a bunch of individually interesting ideas into a screenplay that no longer has an identity.

And I suspect something like that happened with Supergirl. My guess is that the original vision was a much more melancholy character in line with the Woman of Tomorrow comic it was based on. But somewhere during the development process, the movie started moving toward a conventional James Gunn-style space adventure. More humor. More colorful characters.

And the problem is that those two movies don’t necessarily fit together. One wants to be an introspective drama about grief and loss. The other wants to be a fun, irreverent space adventure. Can you combine those things? I guess. But it sure as hell ain’t easy.

Which brings us to one of the most ironic things about the DC Gunn experiment. When he first took over, one of his biggest promises was that he wasn’t going to make the mistake other superhero studios were making. He was going to make sure the scripts were GREAT before giving them a green light.

That sounds wonderful in theory. But in practice? It’s complicated. Because how do you know when a screenplay is great? What happens when you’ve spent two years developing a script, gone through eight drafts, followed all these interesting new directions, and you reach the end only to realize you’ve drifted away from the original movie that got you excited?

Do you start over? Do you throw away two years of work and go back to page one? Or do you convince yourself that your new “best of both worlds” version works? I actually think that if Gunn took a true risk with Supergirl and made the actual comic it was based on, which was much darker, that the movie would’ve done way better.

Which is something all of us writers battle with. Do we do that darker version that’s way riskier or do we do the safer version that’s been proven to work? Gunn ultimately leaned into the latter (“I know this world. It’s Guardians in the DC universe.”) and it was the wrong way to go.  Conversely, I would argue that the risky dark direction Curry Barker took Obsession in, which could have easily had a stock setup with characters doing microfiche investigations in the second act to find out how to stop the curse, is exactly what could happen when you follow a riskier instinct.

The place you really get to study character is in TV. But this is something that these giant franchises still haven’t figured out. Sure, you get to study character more in a TV show. But everybody watching these shows expects more from them since they’re superheroes. So you always end up leaving audiences disappointed.

Sure, every once in a blood red moon you get a Penguin. But those shows are exceptions. After that initial two year honeymoon period when us Star Wars and superhero fans got to see our favorite world on TV, 9 out of every 10 of these shows have been terrible. I still have nightmares about the Jack Black and Lizzo Mandalorian episode.

I think the lesson here is to identify early on the exact movie you want to make. For example, Todd Phillips knew from second one that he wanted his Joker to be The King of Comedy. And every creative decision he made was aligned with that inspiration. He never deviated. It’s okay to follow a screenplay down unexpected paths. But if you’re getting too far away from your original vision, you want to make deathly sure that that’s the direction you want to go.

A few weeks ago, I was getting hammered in the comments for dissing Coyote vs. Acme’s box office performance. I’d pointed out (rightly I may add) that, after all the hoopla and grandstanding about how amazing this canceled movie was, that it only made 15 million bucks when it finally came out.

A bunch of you buried me for it. But I’ve been around Hollywood long enough to know that whenever somebody starts telling you that there’s this AMAZING movie that Hollywood refuses to release, or this AMAZING screenplay that nobody will make, that 99% of the time it’s complete and utter bullshit.

I know this because I’m the guy who went back and read all those “legendary” unproduced screenplays. And what I learned was that nearly all of them sucked! They weren’t these misunderstood works of genius. There were extremely problematic at worst, and average at best.

I’ve always maintained that if something is genuinely good, Hollywood will figure out a way to get it made or release it. Trust me. And Coyote vs. Acme proves my point. It did not languish in obscurity. Somebody bought it and distributed it.

Well, I finally watched it. And while I wouldn’t call the movie great, I have to admit that it may contain the single greatest adaptation idea for difficult material that I’ve ever come across. I’m serious. I was blown away by how clever the entry point into this story was.

Imagine walking into a Hollywood producer’s office and the producer says, “There’s this coyote. And he chases this bird.” Silence. Then, “Go!”

THAT’S THE PREMISE YOU’RE BEING ASKED TO BUILD A MOVIE OUT OF!

These cartoons were designed to be two or three-minute little stories where a coyote sets up some elaborate trap, the trap backfires, and that’s it. See you next week. It’s arguably the most two-dimensional premise in the history of storytelling.

But here’s where the genius comes in. Somebody realized that all those Acme products Wile E. Coyote uses, the rockets, the explosives, the catapults, the whatever-the-hell-else-he’s ordering, NEVER WORK. They always malfunction. So what if they were defective? And what if Wile E. Coyote decided to SUE Acme?

I mean, come on. That’s brilliant! All of a sudden, you’ve got a legal thriller. You’ve got a giant corporation. You’ve got a little guy fighting against the system. You’ve got a mystery surrounding why these products keep failing. You’ve got an actual STORY. I cannot remember the last time I saw somebody find such a clever way into material that seemed impossible to adapt.

Naturally, I wanted to know who the screenwriter was because I was ready to declare him a genius. Well, it turns out the original idea wasn’t the screenwriter’s. It came from a 1990 New Yorker humor piece by Ian Frazier called “Coyote v. Acme,” which imagined Wile E. Coyote taking legal action against the company responsible for all his defective equipment. So Frazier deserves the bulk of the credit here.

But then James Gunn got involved and he came up with the idea to create a buddy comedy with a lawyer. Then screenwriter Samy Burch fleshed the whole thing out into a feature length story.

And I loved what they did with the lawyer, played by Will Forte. He’s this classic, almost “Hero’s Journey” type, protagonist who doesn’t believe in himself. He’s a settler. He’s somebody who’s spent his life backing down, accepting less, never fighting for what he wants.

And now he’s paired with a coyote whose entire existence is built around NEVER GIVING UP. That’s a great character pairing! The whole thing is just really cleverly conceived.

BUT HOW DO YOU FIND THAT ANGLE?

Hollywood is constantly buying up stuff that nobody knows how to turn into a movie. Books. Comics. Board games. Toys. Newspaper articles. Some obscure property from 1974 that a producer remembers loving when he was eight years old. But then once they have the rights, they realize, “Oh shit. How do we actually turn this into a movie???”

That’s where you come in. Once you start selling scripts and getting hired for jobs, a lot of your career is going to consist of walking into rooms and pitching your take on material that doesn’t naturally lend itself to a movie.

And you’re going to be competing against a bunch of other writers who are trying to figure out the exact same thing. Which means your job is to come up with a better angle than everybody else’s.

One of the most famous adaptation examples of all time is Charlie Kaufman. Kaufman, who was hired to adapt Susan Orlean’s book, The Orchid Thief, which was about an orchid collector. And he couldn’t figure out how to turn it into a movie. So what did he do? He wrote a movie about a screenwriter named Charlie Kaufman who couldn’t figure out how to adapt The Orchid Thief! And that’s how we got Adaptation.

I mean, that’s one way to solve your adaptation problem. Unfortunately, most of us would get blacklisted if we tried that stunt.

But the larger point remains. All adaptation is is trying to find the most interesting way into a story. And here’s the part I want you guys to understand. We’re actually all adapting our own material. Even when you’re writing your own original screenplay.

Let’s say you want to write a movie about an alien who shows up on Earth. Okay, great. But what movie are you going to make? Are you going to make E.T., where a little boy befriends the alien? Are you going to make Starman, where the alien takes the form of a woman’s dead husband and we get this romantic road movie? Are you going to make The Thing, where the alien can imitate anybody and suddenly you’ve got this terrifying horror mystery where nobody trusts anybody? Or maybe you’re going to make The Man Who Fell to Earth, where the alien becomes a wealthy businessman. Or Under the Skin, where the alien disguises itself as a beautiful woman and starts luring men to their deaths. Look at how DIFFERENT all those movies are. And yet they all started with essentially the same basic idea. One alien shows up on Earth. There are a MILLION ways into that idea. And your job as a screenwriter is to find the most interesting one.

Which brings me to a movie I was REALLY looking forward to.

ALI G: WHO IZ I?

I told you guys how excited I was to finally get an Ali G movie. I used to LOVE Ali G. Especially during those early internet days when people would post clips of him interviewing politicians and asking them the stupidest questions imaginable. Easily some of the funniest stuff I’ve ever seen.

I always found it strange that Sacha Baron Cohen chose Borat as his big breakout movie instead of Ali G. I always thought Ali G was funnier.

So when I heard we were finally getting an Ali G movie, I was pumped. So I fired the thing up this weekend and… Oh boy.

Oh my.

Oh heavens to Betsy.

The film is a complete and utter failure.

But it’s not all bad because watching this movie proves my very point! Sacha Baron Cohen chose the wrong way into this material.

He took Ali G, this wild, wacky, two-dimensional character whose entire appeal is that he says the most outrageous shit off the cuff, and turned him into a traditional, character-driven protagonist.

You know, the kind of character who has an internal struggle and needs to go on some big emotional journey. So now Ali G is about to become a father. And he’s got to figure out if he’s ready to be a father. And what kind of father he’s going to be. And whether he can handle the responsibility of raising a child. And I’m sitting there thinking…

WHAT THE FUCK WERE YOU THINKING????

This is ALI G! This is the guy who asks Buzz Aldrin if we’ll ever walk on the moon. And now, two minutes later, we’re supposed to sit there and watch him have some thoughtful, sincere moment about the responsibilities of fatherhood?? It doesn’t fit! It doesn’t fit!!!

What’s interesting about this is that, technically, Sacha Baron Cohen is ‘doing the right screenwriting thing.’ Give your character an internal struggle. Give him an emotional journey. Make him grow. Make him confront his fears. I tell you guys to do all the time!

But here’s the problem. Not every character is designed for that.

Ali G isn’t an inner-journey character. He’s an absurd character. His entire appeal is that he says the dumbest things imaginable to people who don’t know how to respond.

You know who understood this? Larry Charles. Charles directed Borat. And what I loved about Borat was that it was just wall-to-wall hijinks. Yes, there was a vague story connecting everything. But the story was there to facilitate the comedy. It wasn’t there to turn Borat into some deeply introspective character who spends half the movie contemplating his emotional shortcomings.

This actually brings us back to something else Coyote vs. Acme got right. They could’ve made Wile E. Coyote talk. Think about how tempting that must’ve been. You’ve got this lawyer who’s going to spend the entire movie with the coyote. Wouldn’t it be easier if they could talk to each other? I’m sure people at the studio pushed HARD for that.

But they didn’t do it. Because Wile E. Coyote DOESN’T TALK. That’s part of what makes him Wile E. Coyote! The second you give him a voice and have him start explaining his feelings, you change the character.

Meanwhile, Sacha Baron Cohen, who directed the new Ali G movie himself, decided to give Ali G this whole fatherhood journey. And point blank it ruined the film. There are still a few funny moments (The therapist character having sex with Ali G in order to steal his DNA – I couldn’t believe what I was watching but I was still laughing my ass off) but then we’d have a 10 minute scene of Ali G in a cab looking forlorn as he contemplated fatherhood.

Which is why I keep coming back to this idea that the most important decision you make as a screenwriter happens BEFORE you write the script. Are you even writing the right version of your movie? Because you can follow every screenwriting rule in the book but if you’re writing the wrong movie, it won’t matter.

THE BOX OFFICE!

Godzilla Minus Zero opened at number one, with an estimated $31 million weekend. Which is a remarkable start for a foreign langue movie. And I’m sure everybody is going to tell me how amazing it is. Just like everybody told me how amazing Godzilla Minus One was. You know what?

NOT GUNNA FALL FOR IT TWICE.

He’s even bigger this time around!

First of all, can we talk about these titles? Godzilla Minus One. Godzilla Minus Zero. WHAT ON GOD’S GREEN EARTH DOES THAT MEAN??? Why are we doing math in our titles????? I know somebody’s going to jump into the comments and explain it to me. I DON’T CARE. You cannot change my mind that these are some of the worst titles in movie history.

WORDS MATTER. We’re writers. And when you give me a title with integers in it, I’m out.

I ended up watching the first Godzilla cause of the great reviews and oh my God. That had to be one of the most boring movies I’ve ever seen. There were these endless stretches of basic, entry-level drama where I was sitting there waiting for Godzilla to show up. And waiting. And waiting.

“But Carson, the human drama is what makes the monster stuff meaningful!” Okay. Okay. But then here’s an idea. MAKE THE HUMAN DRAMA INTERESTING.

Just a thought.

Which brings me to the biggest cheat code in Hollywood: Big monsters sell tickets. If you’re struggling to come up with a movie idea that Hollywood might be interested in, put a giant monster in it and I GUARANTEE your chances of selling the script just went up 100 fold. I’m joking but I’m kinda not.

Now, to be fair, I haven’t seen Minus Zero. But that’s only because I’m still recovering from Long Boredom which I contracted from the first one.

WILD HORSE NINE

And finally, we have Wild Horse Nine. Apparently numbers are the new letters in titles? I don’t know what to say about this movie other than that it looks like somebody found a time machine, traveled back to 2004, grabbed a couple of random film reels, and brought them back to 2026. I mean, Sam Rockwell and John Malkovich? I feel like I should be watching the trailer on QuickTime.

And the funny thing is, it’s getting crazy good reviews! But let’s be real here. The reason this movie has great reviews is because the people seeing it are ALL THE SAME PEOPLE WHO WERE REVIEWING FILMS IN 2004.

I don’t think Diversity Debbie’s Cinema Corner is rushing out to see this flick. If she and her movie buddy critics were, this RT score would be a lottttttt lower I promise you that.

Anyway, that’s it for this week’s movie-watching experiences. If there’s one thing I want you guys to take away from today, it’s don’t assume that the first version of the story you come up with is the right one. There may be a much better movie hiding inside that same concept, and it’s your job to find it.

Keep writing, people!